When traveling abroad, especially within the European Union (EU), there is often confusion about whether a European Health Insurance Card (EHIC) or its replacement, the Global Health Insurance Card (GHIC), is necessary if one already has travel insurance. Both the GHIC and travel insurance serve different purposes and understanding their distinctions and potential overlaps is crucial for travelers.
What is a GHIC?
Purpose of the GHIC
The GHIC is designed to provide access to state-provided healthcare in EU countries and some other countries in the European Economic Area (EEA) and Switzerland at a reduced cost or sometimes for free. It entitles the holder to the same healthcare benefits as a resident of the visited country. This can include essential medical treatment such as doctor visits, hospitalization, and some emergency medical services. The card is based on the principle of reciprocal healthcare agreements between countries.
Coverage Scope
The coverage under a GHIC is limited to medically necessary treatment. It does not cover non-essential services like elective cosmetic surgery or private hospital rooms. It is mainly focused on ensuring that travelers can receive basic healthcare without facing exorbitant costs. For example, if a traveler falls ill with a common ailment like the flu and needs to see a doctor, the GHIC can help cover the cost of that visit.
What is Travel Insurance?
Medical Expense Coverage
Travel insurance typically includes coverage for medical expenses. However, this coverage is broader than that of a GHIC. It can cover not only the cost of medically necessary treatment but also additional expenses such as medical evacuation and repatriation. If a traveler has a serious accident or illness and requires transportation back to their home country for further treatment, travel insurance can pay for the cost of an air ambulance or other forms of medical transport.
Non-medical Coverage
In addition to medical coverage, travel insurance offers protection for other aspects of travel. It can cover trip cancellation if the traveler is unable to go on the trip due to unforeseen circumstances like illness, a family emergency, or the insolvency of a travel company. It also provides coverage for lost or stolen baggage, travel delays, and liability in case the traveler accidentally injures someone or damages property during the trip.
Overlaps and Differences
Medical Treatment Overlap
There is an overlap in the medical treatment coverage between a GHIC and travel insurance. Both can cover the cost of doctor visits and hospitalization for a sudden illness or injury. However, as mentioned, travel insurance offers more extensive coverage for serious medical situations that may require evacuation or repatriation. For example, if a traveler has a heart attack and needs to be transported to a specialized hospital in their home country, the GHIC may not cover this, but travel insurance likely would.
Non-medical Coverage Difference
The major difference is in the non-medical coverage. A GHIC has no provisions for trip cancellation, baggage loss, or liability. Travel insurance provides a comprehensive package that protects the traveler in various non-medical aspects of the trip. If a traveler’s luggage is lost during a flight, the GHIC will not provide any compensation, but travel insurance can reimburse the value of the lost items.
When a GHIC May be Sufficient
Short Trips within the EU
For short trips within the EU where the likelihood of a major medical emergency requiring evacuation or repatriation is low, a GHIC may be sufficient. If a traveler is going on a weekend getaway to a nearby EU country and has no pre-existing medical conditions, the GHIC can cover the basic medical needs that may arise. The traveler may choose to rely on the GHIC and forego travel insurance for that particular short trip.
Travelers with Comprehensive Home Country Healthcare
Some travelers may have comprehensive healthcare coverage in their home country that extends to some extent when they are traveling abroad. If this is the case and the traveler is only concerned about basic medical treatment while in the EU, a GHIC in combination with their home country coverage might be enough. For example, a traveler from a country with a national health service that has reciprocal agreements with EU countries may feel comfortable with just a GHIC for a short visit.
When Travel Insurance is Essential
Long or Frequent Trips
For long trips or frequent travelers, travel insurance is essential. The longer the trip, the greater the chance of something going wrong, whether it’s a medical emergency, lost baggage, or a trip cancellation. Frequent travelers also face a higher cumulative risk over time. Travel insurance provides the peace of mind and comprehensive protection needed for extended or repeated travels.
High-risk Activities or Destinations
If a traveler is engaging in high-risk activities such as extreme sports or traveling to destinations with political instability or a high crime rate, travel insurance is crucial. The GHIC will not cover any injuries or losses related to these high-risk situations. For example, if a traveler is going skiing in the Alps and gets injured, travel insurance can cover the cost of treatment and any associated rescue operations, while a GHIC may only cover basic medical treatment at a local facility.
Conclusion
Whether one needs a GHIC if they have travel insurance depends on various factors. While a GHIC can provide basic medical coverage in EU countries and some related areas, travel insurance offers a more comprehensive package that includes not only extended medical protection but also coverage for non-medical aspects of travel. Short trips within the EU by healthy individuals may be adequately covered by a GHIC alone, but for most other travel scenarios, especially long trips, frequent travel, high-risk activities, or travel to less stable destinations, travel insurance is highly recommended. It is important for travelers to carefully consider their specific travel plans and needs before deciding whether to rely solely on a GHIC or to also invest in travel insurance.
Related topics
